Thinking and the Future · 02
My First Date with GrokBot
Working with AI is a lot like dating. One side thinks it is placing an order. What it actually hands over is a mood.
Working with AI is a lot like dating.
One side thinks it is placing an order. What it actually hands over is a mood.
One side is sure it has said everything clearly. The other side hears, “You figure it out.”
And when you tell someone to figure it out, the result is usually hard to look at.
The story has to start at the beginning.
I write songs on the side. An amateur. A pile of my own demos sits on a hard drive. I have always wanted to turn them into music videos, and I have never wanted the trouble.
So I did something a little reckless. I opened a chat and told GrokBot: you are my music-video producer. Start with the song on my drive, That Isn't My Moon, and make the video.
It said: okay.
That one word sounded full of promise.
When the first cut opened, I stared at the screen for three seconds.
Cold. Dull. Gray.
Far too gloomy.
It felt like a tender love song left in the fridge.
I said: whose moon is this? It isn't mine.
GrokBot probably thought it had already tried. The pictures were there. The words were there. The song was in there.
What more do you want?
Right. Technically it was all correct. Aesthetically it was all wrong.
The first version proved only one thing.
It could not hear which moon I had in mind.
There was a difference, though.
Fight too long with a girlfriend and you might break up.
Fight with GrokBot, and I go scroll my phone while it keeps working.
A lot of people think working with AI is writing a prompt.
It isn't.
It is much closer to working with an actual person.
You make a mess first, then you season it over and over.
I said: not gloomy. Warm. Bright.
It adjusted.
I said I wanted this gold, this blue-green.
It adjusted again.
I said the light still was not enough. The picture needed a story.
An escort, an ambush, falling in love, letting go, and at the end one person standing in the moonlight.
Suddenly it had a feeling.
In the end I threw out the technical approach too.
Quit pretending this is a movie camera. Switch to slides.
By then our chat read like a couple keeping house: no sweetness, no encouragement.
Only “no,” “this is a mess,” and “use your head.”
When the finished piece finally came out, I was not especially excited. I was calm.
Because it was already clear.
This video was not an AI burst of inspiration, and it was not my stroke of genius. It was the two of us wearing each other in.
I wore it down until it learned how to take a note. It wore me down until I learned how to give one.
The rejects pile up in the folder. The finished piece sits on top.
Without those rejects, the top layer would never have appeared.
So this is not some myth of one-click generation. It is improvement that does not stop.
The song is still That Isn't My Moon.
But in the end, it really became the moon I wanted.
That's the end. Goodbye, and I hope you enjoy it.